Questions? Give us an email at or visit our Help Desk

Do you want to go to the WRONG college? Do these 5 things.

  • The 4-year graduation rate in the US is approximately 40%.

    This means that you are more likely to add additional years to your degree (or drop out of college) than to graduate in 4 years.

    Scary right?

    In fact, about 39% of students transfer to another college or drop out altogether after freshman year.

    What is the reason for these statistics? Why is the transfer rate so high and the 4-year graduation rate so low? The answer is generally that many students are making the decision to attend colleges that are not a good fit for them. This is usually because of a flawed college sports recruiting process.

    Sports Recruiting: 5 Ways To End Up At The Wrong College

    The 5 points below are some of the strategies that could lead you to the wrong college.

    1. Not thinking through college FIT

    Many student-athletes focus primarily on the athletic component to drive their college recruiting process, asking questions such as “which division should I be aiming for?” and “what team am I good enough to play for?” and forming an initial college list based on these types of athletic questions. 

    Athlete Match has learned from 30 years of working with colleges and college coaches that this type of athletic-centric approach is actually harmful for student-athletes, greatly increasing the potential for a poor college outcome. Athlete Match advocates a different approach to evaluating and selecting colleges: finding colleges that are a good fit both on and off the field. Read more here.

    1. Using Recruiting Technology Without Guidance

    Consider this metaphor: using recruiting technology without guidance is like driving in a foreign country without a map – the car will help you get somewhere faster, but will you arrive at your desired destination? Probably not. 

    What does your ‘desired destination’ look like in the recruiting process? It looks like committing to a school that is a good fit for you as a student-athlete: academically, socially and athletically. This will lead to an excellent 4-year experience and also set you up for success after college. Guidance should work alongside technology to get you recruited to your best fit schools, showing you how to use various recruiting tools for your best possible outcome. Read more here.

    1. Being Reactive Instead of Proactive

    Consider this example: Tommy is a soccer player from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. As a high school junior, Tommy has been attending different soccer tournaments and camps for the past year. He has been contacted by 5 different schools and added them all to his list. Tommy ranked the 5 schools based on the level of interest he received from each college coach: 1. Colgate 2. Boston College 3. James Madison 4. Davidson and 5. UNC Asheville. Nothing appears to be wrong with this list…until you learn a little bit more about Tommy. 

    Tommy wants to go to school in-state because it will be cheaper and he doesn’t want to be more than 2 hours from home. He also prefers the feel of a large school with more than 10,000 undergraduate students. Although he has not decided on a major yet, he is very interested in an Astrobiology minor. 

    Now that we know this information about Tommy, his ‘Top 5’ list of colleges does not look very good anymore! If Tommy visits these schools (or worse, commits) he will quickly discover that they are not a good overall Fit for him. Tommy’s reactive approach to creating his list of colleges led him to consider a number of schools that did not suit him at all. He got distracted by the interest that he received from college coaches and focused too much on athletics. 

    There is nothing wrong with being excited about schools contacting you, but you must research them for Fit before adding them to your list. 

    1. Contact as many coaches as possible, while using generic email templates.

    Most sports recruiting companies advise you to mass email as many coaches as you can. They think that the more you reach out to, the more might reply. How many freshmen can identify 50 colleges they are actually interested in? The 50 colleges that receive that generic email (they get thousands of those each year) will hit the delete button. You are also much more likely to reach out to schools that aren’t even a good fit for you.

    Read more about how to engage effectively with college coaches here.

    1. Only Thinking About Athletics In The Sports Recruiting Process

    We often hear this statement from high school students that do not prioritize academic achievement: “I’m not a great student, but grades and test scores don’t matter as long as I’m a great athlete. The coach will still want me.” Yes, if you are a fantastic athlete/player the coach will probably want you, but the university won’t and that’s a big problem. Believe it or not, it’s the college that has the final say on whether or not you will be accepted, not the college coach. Read more here.

    Be sure to avoid these missteps to help ensure that you don’t make the wrong college decision. If you want help finding your best fit college, talking to coaches, being proactive and ultimately having a successful sports recruiting outcome – Create a Free Profile today, learn more here, or try our search & filter tool for free.